Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Darren Aronofsky's Black Swan

I was living in St. Louis in 1998 when Darren Aronofsky’s Pi premiered at the Tivoli Theater in University City. It hit the screens with very little fanfare. I never saw a trailer, never read a review. I knew nothing more about this movie than what the blurb on the marquee and the lines down the block told me. For some reason people were going to see this movie in droves. After a couple of weeks of wondering why, I decided to pop in and check it out. I was floored.  Pi was gritty and original. An entirely unexpected arthouse hit.  It was immediately obvious that Darren Aronofsky was on his way.
In the years that followed, Aronofsky remained in the cinema spotlight either through the handful of movies he made, or through the multitude of ones that he didn’t. Few can compete with his contributions to the film geek rumor mill. For years there seemed to be constant speculation on the director’s involvement in everything from audacious pet projects to studio tent pole flicks. He was long pegged to be the director of choice for Warner Bros’ reboot of the Batman franchise, a job which eventually went to his comparable contemporary Christopher Nolan.  But through all of this conjecture, Aronofsky has managed to stay away from the superbudget Hollywood hype pics and has kept to more personal projects like Requiem for a Dream, The Wrestler, and the (overly?) ambitious The Fountain.
His latest film, Black Swan, fits perfectly within his catalog to date. It’s a relatively small, arthouse movie with the ambition to achieve the scope of an epic. This is the tricky balancing act that Aronofsky has been attempting for his entire career.  The success of this feat requires a certain set of cinematic tools, some of which Aronofsky possesses.
 Aronofsky is a master of visceral filmmaking. There are few, if any, active directors who are better able to convey to an audience the physical anguish of a character. His style is reminiscent of a literary concept first introduced to me at a reading by the author Chuck Palahniuk. He talked about a writing tool he utilizes called “On the Body” which he described as a way to use physical sensations like injuries and other ailments to induce the audience into an empathetic relationship with his characters.  Aronofsky seems to cinematically embrace this concept. He is highly adept at drawing the viewer into a somatic sympathy with the inhabitants of his films. In that context, Black Swan may be his best work.
On my first viewing of Black Swan, I found myself literally moved. It’s been a long time since a film made me, and the people around me, jump and cringe as much as this one. It reminded me of the early work of Roman Polanski in its ability to seduce the audience into actual physical involvement. That interactive quality lends itself beautifully to the sub-theme of physiological deterioration which pervades the entire picture. As each scene follows the last, it creates a compilation of visual and auditory body blows that work to drag the viewer down the spiral into which Nina (Natalie Portman) is sliding.  On that level, the film works.  But Black Swan isn’t just about a character’s physical degradation. It’s about a descent into madness. It’s about the psyche of a performer being torn apart as she delves into her darker self. To fully express this theme one must place the audience in the character’s mind. Make us understand what it means to actually step over the line of sanity and completely lose control. But is Aronofsky as adept at putting us in the head of the character as he is at putting us “on the body”?
On a second look, with all of the shock and awe of the initial screening washed away, Black Swan simply came up short. I spent this second viewing disinterested in the physical aspects of the character’s journey and instead spent it searching for the soul of the picture. I was completely unable to get a grasp on it. While it is a technically outstanding film, it is a mediocre story; unoriginal and tired. Thematically, it is a film we’ve all seen a thousand times before from De Palma’s Sisters to David Fincher’s Fight Club.   But the story of Black Swan fails not only in unoriginality of theme but in its unimaginative visual execution. Aronofsky often uses hackneyed imagery (repetitive mirror images, endless hallucinatory double-takes) to express Nina’s slip from sanity. Many of these basic tropes can be found in the multitude of straight to video horror flicks that are churned out on a weekly basis. Simply put, Black Swan lacks the story to match its package and with all its beautiful cinematography, textured sound design, and impressive performances it adds up to nothing more than a cheap thrill-ride in an arthouse disguise.  
This realization concerning Black Swan made me reconsider the whole of Aronofsky’s career.  Thinking back to the times I’ve rewatched his previous films, I remember how impactful they seemed at first, and how poorly they held up. Broken down to their bare elements I start to see that there just isn’t any truth in them. Aronofsky’s an illusionist, a master of misdirection. For the most part this isn’t a bad trait for a filmmaker to have but it does leave one susceptible to exposure once the illusion is washed away. When the bells-and-whistles echo out, the heart of an artist is revealed.  Aronofsky just doesn’t have the heart.  At the center of each of his films is a sensationalized and superficial perspective which comes across as inhuman and cold. Perhaps the only truly “human” film in his repertoire is his 2008 film The Wrestler, and one could argue that the depth of that film is entirely attributable to Mickey Rourke’s raw and empathetic  performance. Luckily for Aronofsky, good performers tend to tag along with prestigious directors, no matter how dubiously earned that prestige may be.
After more than a decade in the arthouse, Aronofsky has finally decided to stop sidestepping the studios and has signed on to direct next year’s The Wolverine, a massive tent pole Marvel Comics project which will reunite him with his The Fountain costar Hugh Jackman. It’ll be interesting to see how Aronofsky’s visceral style melds with the world of superhuman fight sequences and over the top CG effects. And Wolverine might be the perfect character for him to explore. He’s simple, archetypal, and in a constant state of pain. Aronofsky may be the perfect director for a project like this. Hollywood may be the perfect place for him after all.     

Tuesday, January 18, 2011

True Grit

Editor’s note:
Some of you may have read my previous blog entry where I stated, in a post script, my intentions to keep a strict critical distance from the subject of my reviews. Never mind that. I realized after some thought that any attempt to adhere to such a promise may prove limiting to my ability to write in a thorough and honest manner. One’s personal worldview, coupled with their previous experience with the art form, are necessary elements to their ability to write on the subject of film.
I hope the following post will demonstrate not only that how I intend to now completely contradict the idea of strict objectivity but also how willing I am to waffle and unashamedly edit myself after the fact. It’s a blog. I think it’s almost imperative to let myself come through in it. I also hope that what you are presumably about to read will demonstrate further the points I made the first installment of the Twice Seen blog.  
So, for those of you who read my previous post in its original form, the post script has been removed. And for those of you who never read it, I never wrote it.  
Thanks,
John

TRUE GRIT

I can’t remember the last time I was as excited about an upcoming film as I was when I heard that the Coen Brothers were making their version John Wayne’s Oscar winning classic True Grit. I grew up with “The Duke” and True Grit was a regular in the limited rotation of films I was allowed to watch as I grew to manhood in the bucolic abyss of rural Missouri. I must have watched that movie twenty times when I was a kid and I never got tired of it. It was second only to Rio Bravo on my list of Wayne Westerns and ranked pretty high among the few films I’d watched in my short and sheltered life.
Of course, that was my youth. And as you may have deduced from the paragraph above I was not exactly steeped in cinematic experience.  My family was quite religious, and the content of the television shows and movies we watched was closely monitored to say the least. There were very few modern movies that I was allowed to see, which was very frustrating for a kid of that time and with my interest in that line of entertainment. I can’t tell you how many times I had to stand aside and endure the endless reenactments and energetic praise of movies like Ghostbusters and Raiders of the Lost Ark without any point of reference. I could really only participate if the subject were Star Wars, but even that had its limitations. I’ll never forget that summer night in 1983when my folks came home from their parental preview of Return of the Jedi to tell me that I COULDN’T see it. Too scary they said. I was devastated. Perhaps if I would have seen ROTJ when I was nine I would have actually enjoyed it. I guess I’ll never know.
Being that we were such a wholesome household, classic films were the safest choice for rental.  When it came to keeping it clean you could always depend on the strict censorship of the old Hollywood studio system and their Production Code. If the movie was older than the MPAA rating system then it was deemed okay, otherwise it pretty much had had to be Rated G.  Truthfully, most of what we watched depended greatly on my dad and what he could stand to sit through. He preferred War Movies and Westerns so those made up much of my early film education. Of course, these violent, manly movies didn’t always go over well with my mom and sister. True Grit was an exception. With its female protagonist and classic western storyline, it held something for all of us.
Growing up a as a budding film buff, I didn’t really care what we watched. I devoured movies with the all the discretion of a starving goat. I would watch anything my parents would put on that 26” screen. The only movie we owned after we first got a VCR was a recorded-from-TV tape of Blake Edwards’ The Great Race. I literally watched that movie over 200 times and for those who’ve seen it, you now know how undiscerning I was. But I also watched a lot of Hitchcock, Hawks, and Ford and it was those names that made me think about the men behind the camera. By the age of twelve all I cared about was movies and who made them. And while classic cinema was a great way to get a grasp on the basics, it only offered so much for a growing boy who was so ravenous for more stimulating styles and content. My sensibilities drastically evolved, as did my parent’s approach to censoring the movies I watched. This heightened sophistication and freedom of choice occurred for me in the late 80s and early 90s. About the time Joel and Ethan Coen were really making a name for themselves in the film game.
Much of my understanding of cinema comes from the Coen Bros and their unique style of movie making. I’ve followed their career closely and I have felt for a long time that they are perhaps the most consistently original and technically proficient directors presently working in the industry. They have a firm handle on nearly every genre: from comedies like The Big Lebowski to existential thrillers like No Country for Old Men. Those films, along with the rest of their quality catalog earned them a fervent fan following, a few well earned Oscars, and have placed these Minnesota natives in the pantheon with the giants of Cinema history.
So when the Coens announced their first jaunt into the world of the traditional Western, people all over the film geek community immediately hit the roof. No one was more amped excited than me. I went out and bought the book. I followed every rumor and casting confirmation. I checked almost daily for screen caps and a possible release date. I geeked out. And why wouldn’t I? The Coen Brothers, two of my favorite filmmakers were making True Grit, one of my favorite childhood movies. What could be more ideal?
All of this, as you may have guessed, only set an impossible standard. The Coen Brother’s True Grit could never be what I hoped it would be. I should have known that it would fall victim to one of the most prevalent enemies of both objective critique and simple enjoyment:  overblown expectations.
Upon my initial viewing, I thought the Coen’s True Grit was just okay. I liked it to a certain extent and certainly found it to be a vast improvement over more recent, middling attempts at the traditional western such as James Mangold’s 3:10 To Yuma or Ed Harris’ Appaloosa. It was also a big step up from Henry Hathaway’s 1969 version which from a more seasoned perspective, plays like a top notch TV movie. But improvement was the least of what I expected form the Coen’s revision and with that cast and the talent behind the camera, was all but granted. I came to that 11 AM, opening day showing expecting to get blown away. That just didn’t happen. True Grit didn’t have the pop and luster I’ve come to expect from the Coens and their production team. Didn’t have the visual flair I hoped for. The performances often seemed stiff. I found it funny in parts but didn’t sense the rich pathos found in some of their most notable efforts. To me, the whole film felt plodding and awkward. I was disappointed to say the least. 
Of course, that was my first viewing, and while I spent the day moping about my earlier disappointment I realized rather quickly that I would have to give it another chance. I went back two days later on Christmas Eve, appropriately enough with my parents in tow. What I saw that day was an entirely different picture. From the opening frame, I knew that I had gotten it wrong.
What a beautiful shot: A point of light in soft focus through a haze of snowfall.  A piano eases into the sound track playing a familiar hymn. As we’re slowly brought into focus, we see a body lying lifeless beneath a pair of glowing gas lights. A voiceover begins, inviting us into the thoughts of our young protagonist. The whole scene was like a gentle embrace. I knew I was in good hands again and being put at ease, was ready to accept everything that came after. One mark of true cinema masters is their ability to pull you in and convince you thoroughly of their vision. This is largely a matter of tone. The tone set in the prologue of True Grit is pitch-perfect and it rings like a tuning fork through the entirety of the film that follows.
Now adjusted to a new point of view, I was immediately able to accept the context of True Grit. It is a marked departure from some of the Coen’s recent offerings like No Country for Old Men or the wildly underrated A Serious Man. Those films were layered with existential complexity and their visual style was appropriately more sophisticated. True Grit’s story is simple, so its style is simple. Shot with sparing subtlety by Roger Deakins and classically cut by the Coens themselves, it stands as a prime example of a work from artists with a keen contextual awareness. The camera movement is reserved and oftentimes barely noticeable. The transitions are traditional, with multiple dissolves and fade outs. The end of the first act even comes with a preparing-for-the-journey montage and a letter-to-mom voiceover. Old fashioned stuff to be sure, but this is an old fashioned movie, as it should be. The Coens are as committed to a visual style befitting the story as they are to the authenticity of the language.  This attention to detail and proper tone comes together to create a believable world for its cast of characters.  
 As far as the performances go, I was certainly most excited about Jeff Bridges. I could easily envision him as the grizzly Rooster Cogburn before I ever saw a frame of film. Bridges is a legend and he morphs so effortlessly into the surly old marshal that it’s almost anticlimactic. The truly impressive performances were those turned in by Matt Damon as the loquacious Texas Ranger LaBoeuf and the newcomer Hailie Steinfeld as the headstrong Mattie Ross.
One thing I felt upon my first viewing and still feel after a second is that Damon almost steals the show. As a character actor, this bonafide superstar continues to exhibit a capacity to transform himself into humorous and quirky characters while still injecting them with appropriately subtle hints of human depth. While this role serves a different purpose than his amazing and largely overlooked performance in last year’s The Informant!, it is equally impressive. Mostly comic in nature, it still contains a similar complexity.  The scene he shares with Steinfeld as he departs the camp is one of the more emotionally resonant of the film. His defeat is palpable, as is his respect and sympathy for the young girl. To that point in the story he had been a cartoon; a blowhard, physically and egotistically beaten to the cusp of slapstick. In the scene at the camp we see something different. LaBoeuf is actually the anchor of this misguided trio and Mattie must look to him as her last hope. But he doesn’t coddle to the girl. He offers her, and the audience, sober reality. The trail is cold. She should go back home to her mother. In that moment, I believe that the Ranger is the only truly responsible character in the whole film. Quite a transformation from the buffoon of a few scenes earlier.    
Hailie Steinfeld’s debut performance as Mattie Ross is definitely one for the books.  This young girl, with only a handful of shorts and TV gigs to her credit, brings a real intelligence and natural innocence to the role; something that was honestly lacking with Kim Darby’s portrayal in the original. Steinfeld’s Ross remains believably fearless and unphased throughout the film, with only a flash of girlishness breaking through with the occasional smile. She’s a little girl in the violent world of men and through simple strength of will manages to hold her own.  It’s not until she’s completed her mission and exacted revenge on the murderous Tom Chaney that that world catches up to her. It’s here that Steinfeld and the Coens allow the character to buckle and revert back to the little girl she truly is.
Snake-bitten and dying, Ross must be carried out of that wild country by the now paternal Cogburn. Through a series of simple, but effective POV shots, the directors show us Ross’ journey past the bodies of the vanquished villains, out of their violent world, and across the great distance that separates her from safety. As they ride across the snowy expanse the little girl starts to pour out through the cracks of the stern façade Ross and Steinfeld have maintained throughout the film. She begs for the life her horse, even at the expense of her own and wails against its mercy killing like a child unfettered by the reality of the situation. It has now become a simple matter of a girl and her horse. Another beautiful transformation.  
I won’t begrudge Steinfeld the credit for her fine performance, but the genius of it could be attributed to the Coen’s casting of this legitimate newcomer. Steinfeld and Ross are charged with a similar task: to enter an unknown world and hold their own. For an unseasoned teenage girl to be thrown in the mix with film legends like Jeff Bridges and the Coen Brothers is tantamount to a face-off with a gang of motley Wild West villains. Ross exhibits little fear in the face of danger and the same could be said for Steinfeld. Perhaps the effortlessness she exhibits in this role is due to fact that she must behave in the same fashion as the character she’s playing. But even if the success of this performance could be credited to the caginess of the Coens and their casting department there should be no lack of respect for the nubile young actress. She definitely stood up to the challenge.
I feel it’s appropriate that my review of True Grit is the first official entry to Twice Seen. My experience with this film should illustrate more succinctly the validity of the conceit for which I’ve based this blog. While I assure my few readers that every article written for this site will not speak directly to the concepts set out in the blog’s manifesto, I thought it would be a good idea to demonstrate these concepts through example, more than by mere conjecture. Our understanding of a film is largely contingent upon our understanding of the films that have come before it. Perhaps, this statement holds even more truth when considering a remake of a cherished classic by filmmakers so closely studied and admired. Sorry I doubted you Coen Brothers.

True Grit is an instance where a film failed only its inability to live up to an initial set of impossible expectations. In every other way it is an absolute success. Maybe now I should give Burn After Reading another look.

Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Upon a Second Reading: The Twice Seen Manifesto

 I doubt if it would be presumptuous of me to say that most moviegoers, casual or otherwise, are disenchanted with the world of film criticism. I count myself in their ranks, though I'm decidedly not of the former category. Casualness is not an approach this author often takes to movie watching, nor to the critical reading of a film. I feel confident when I say that many of the Metacritic mandated members of the critical community do not share my contemplative approach. 

One reason for this lack of contemplation is that many movie reviewers must take it upon themselves to voice an opinion on every film they see. A daunting task to be sure. I respect the sheer amount of effort required in writing an articulate article on the subject of three or more different films a week. The problem with this method is that it overworks the writer, and therefore diminishes the quality of the work. These critics see these films and churn out reviews based on a blur of screenings. In this critical climate, studied review devolves into an exercise in the pontification of the author's taste. An inevitable byproduct of a first impression.

Which brings me to the reason for the existence (and the name) of this blog.

The purpose of Twice Seen is to provide a meditative, studied approach to the art of cinematic critique. This will be accomplished by adhering to one simple rule: I (or anyone else in association with this blog) will never write a review on a film having only seen it once. 

I would make other declarations about the disparity between this blog and the slurry of other more prominent filmic writings but I feel it would be unnecessary. Simply sticking to the rule of basing my readings on second (or more) impressions, I feel, will largely eradicate many of the flaws inherent in the hurried world of movie review. I would, however, like to list a few traits that will be unique to this blog.

1) There will not be a review on every movie released. I do not think it is necessary to write on every damn thing that Hollywood slots in every weekend.

2) Many of the films deemed worthy of review will not be new releases. If I, or a visiting writer, have an interesting idea about a critical piece whether it concerns Birth of a Nation or Black Swan, we will write on it.

3) There will be spoilers. Another major gripe I have with movie critics concerns their treatment of "spoilers". Many writers literally structure their reviews upon the actual plot of the film. Obviously this reveals more than a reader should know prior to their own viewing. And it's just lazy writing. Conversely, many critics refuse to discuss elements of a film's plot which are necessary to a comprehensive presentation of their review. They waste so much energy writing (or talking) around certain aspects of the film that their reading of it takes a back seat to "spoiler panic". The reviews presented by Twice Seen WILL CONTAIN SPOILERS. However, they will NOT be synoptic relays of the films in discussion.

Lastly, I would like to make it clear that I do not consider myself more enlightened or more knowledgeable about cinema than many of the people who call themselves film critics. And I certainly don't consider myself to be a better writer. I don't question the intentions of (most of) these authors and I applaud the fact that they were passionate enough about movies to put in the work required to make a go of it in the business of film journalism. It's the business itself that I question, and the resultant critical method.

I'm sure that there are others out there who think the way I do, and there's probably something out in the blogosphere of a similar ilk to the idea I'm presenting. I hope there is. I'm not claiming an original idea or hoping to corner the market. I hope everyone who writes about film does so in a studied, contemplative way and that they are all willing to give a movie a second look and not let their shitty mood, or their inability to immediately grasp a movie's complexities dissuade them from appreciating what might be a wonderful work of art. I hope you, as readers, do the same.

Thanks

John Ingle

Twice Seen